The old playbook doesn’t work anymore. In the last cycle, projects launched tokens first and built products later. They relied on incentives, airdrops, and speculative hype to manufacture traction. It was easy to attract “users” when everyone was chasing points and yield. But that era is over. The users that remain are smarter, more skeptical, and immune to token bait. Real adoption now happens before a token exists, not because of one.

The End of Mercenary Adoption

From 2020 to 2022, liquidity mining, airdrops, and emissions built entire ecosystems on borrowed attention. The model worked as long as new buyers replaced the last. When markets corrected, most of those users vanished. The result was clear: mercenary liquidity doesn’t stick, and fake usage can’t be monetized.

At the same time, regulation changed the risk calculus. Teams can no longer hide behind “community distribution” while running unregistered public offerings. Investors started valuing usage and retention over hype. And exchanges began filtering out projects with synthetic metrics.

Today, launching a token early signals weakness. It tells investors the product cannot attract users without incentives. It tells traders that the float will expand before real demand exists. And it tells your community that your priority is hype, not utility.

What Early Adoption Really Means

Early adoption isn’t TVL, Discord members, or inflated volume. It’s proof that people care about your product when there’s nothing to speculate on. It shows up as feedback loops, not token pumps.

There are three kinds of early adoption that matter in Web3. The first is builder adoption, developers integrate or build on top of you because it makes sense technically. The second is power user adoption, a small, consistent cohort that uses your app daily and reports bugs because they believe in it. The third is narrative adoption, when your name starts coming up in conversations as “the team actually building something real.”

Founders often underestimate the third one. Narratives are how crypto allocates attention. Being early to a narrative without a token gives you leverage when the cycle turns. You become the default project in that niche before the crowd even knows it exists.

How To Get Users Without a Token

The most credible projects in this cycle built momentum without emissions. They focused on frictionless products, storytelling, and culture. Their community joined because of curiosity and alignment, not because of a points system.

Start by opening a gated beta, not a public campaign. Let in the right users, developers, traders, and power testers who care about the mission. Give them recognition, not tokens. People value access and belonging more than meaningless points.

Be transparent about your progress. Post development updates. Share analytics and lessons. Show that you’re solving problems in real time. In an ecosystem saturated with stealth launches and overpromised whitepapers, honesty is the strongest marketing.

Next, build loops around contribution. Reward users with visibility. Create leaderboards, not yield farms. Collect meaningful data, retention, average session time, on-chain interactions, instead of vanity metrics like signups or total testnet volume. Tokens amplify momentum. They do not create it.

If your product can’t attract users without paying them, you don’t have a product yet.

Strategic Levers for Pre-Token Growth

Narrative is your first growth lever. Shape your story early and control it. Why does your product exist, and what shift in user behavior does it enable? Projects that win are those that can articulate why their existence matters in ten seconds.

Partnerships are your second lever. Integrate where user flows already exist. Collaborate with protocols or infrastructure players that align with your mission. Early integrations compound credibility faster than paid marketing.

Technical transparency is the third lever. Expose your APIs or SDKs early. Let developers test integrations and build around you. Open feedback channels. Projects that treat developers as partners, not customers, build stickier ecosystems.

Social loops are your final lever. In 2025, influence is distributed. Micro-communities on X, Telegram, and Farcaster move more attention than paid campaigns. Build relationships with creators and analysts who can validate your story through data and usage, not sponsorship.

If you plan to work with liquidity partners or market makers, involve them early. Prepare liquidity and infrastructure long before you deploy a token. A stable launch isn’t just about depth on day one; it’s about preventing price distortions that can ruin a narrative in hours.

When You’re Actually Ready To Launch

A project is ready to launch a token only when users would be frustrated if you didn’t. You need real metrics that prove retention and demand. You need a functioning product that solves something people do regularly without rewards. You need tokenomics that make sense in the context of your product, not as a replacement for it.

Most importantly, you need data and partners who can translate that traction into responsible liquidity. Launching a token should scale what works, not mask what doesn’t.

The New Meta: Credibility Over Hype

Tokens used to manufacture trust. Now they test it. Launching a token before you have users is the loudest way to show you don’t believe your product can stand on its own. Launching one after users arrive tells the market you’re serious.

Web3 isn’t about who can airdrop the most points or buy the most influencers. It’s about who can attract attention with real utility and retain it without paying people to stay. The next generation of winners will not mint hype, they’ll mint credibility.

Web3 didn’t die. It matured. The new game is simple: earn adoption before you tokenize it.

‍